“WHAT POLITICIANS TALK ABOUT”

Reach — Citation — Content
Within the project we track the activity of the leaders of political ratings every week and report on their statements that reached the largest probable internet audience in Ukraine and therefore had the best chance of being heard. To determine “What politicians talk about”, their statements go through a multi-level review: we identify politicians’ statements spread in the top 100 online media and build a top list of statements for each selected politician; we check how the list spread across our entire database of over 5,000 online media aggregated by our search system Shukach; for each statement we calculate the probable number of audience contacts as the sum of the average daily reach of the outlets (based on panel research by our partners Factum Group). The result is concise, comprehensive information on what the leaders of opinion polls are saying, how they react to political events and how they shape the agenda.

Back to top Archive publications…

The #ReadCarefully project “Interviews: measuring journalists’ effectiveness”

The #ReadCarefully project by NOKS FISHES and the Centre for Public Policy and Communications Research continues to follow interviews with Ukraine’s top politicians. A political interview is a dialogue in which the journalist seeks answers to questions that matter to society and conveys information to readers, while the politician aims to spread information in the desired form and convince society of their value as a representative of power. Within #ReadCarefully we analyse interviews with Ukraine’s leading politicians and assess how well the journalists did their job and how sincerely the politicians answered.

#ReadCarefully is also:

a transparent technology based on four dimensions of how an interview is conducted:

- clarity of the question, the author’s judgement within the question, evasion of questions, journalists returning to questions (measured in per cent)

and three dimensions of the journalist’s professional approach to preparing the interview text:

- the text’s summary, knowledge of the topic, control of the topic (rated on a 5-point scale). In addition, for each interview we record the main topics of the conversation and those the politician wanted to avoid, as well as how often other media quoted the interview.

Back to top

The “Value Indicators” project

Content analysis of public figures based on the Schwartz matrix (European values) and other expert studies by NOKs fishes

Project methodology:

Step 1: summarising the value models of European countries (based on research by the European Sociological Association). We used Shalom Schwartz’s theory of basic human values, applied in the European Social Survey and other cross-cultural projects;

Step 2: forming an expert pool for an online survey; using the Schwartz scale, experts defined the value framework of the ideal Ukrainian politician and assessed how well a number of Ukrainian politicians match these values. We sought experts who represent the proto-elite, hold pro-European values themselves and know Ukrainian politics well. We thank every expert who found the time to take part pro bono;

Step 3: 30 members of the national political class were selected to determine each one’s value profile and compare it with the value matrix of the “ideal” Ukrainian politician. Unable to study all Ukrainian politicians, we formed a sample of 30 people with different roles, ages and political affiliations, all with significant influence on public opinion, including on society’s value model;

Step 4: defining — through expert assessment in the online survey — the value profile of the ideal Ukrainian politician and comparing it with the existing value models of European societies;

Step 5: identifying — through the online expert survey — the value profile of each of the 30 politicians studied. The survey closed on 30 November 2016, so the politicians’ positions during the budget process and their reaction to high-profile events (such as the “open letters of oligarchs”) fell outside the study period and did not affect the experts’ assessments;

Step 6: to assess how the politicians’ vocabulary matches these values, we analysed their personal content (Facebook posts, blog entries, print interviews, official speeches, etc.) from 1 May to 30 September 2016 and measured the frequency of value-laden words.

Image

Baseline study, March 2017

In our view, however much is said about the crisis of European identity (a fact that is hard to deny), it is European humanist values — which as early as the 16th century placed the human being at the centre of the universe — that remain the benchmarks shaping the fate and the rules of life of the most successful countries. Respect for the individual, care for others, self-reliance, responsibility, equality before the law, independence, innovation, honesty, determination, a love of beauty and the pursuit of happiness are the defining features of the European mindset and, in a way, the foundation of the Western world’s success.

We will be glad to hear your feedback on our work and ideas

Analysts’ comments

  • “Projects like these are needed not only by PR professionals and political consultants but also by ordinary citizens: we live at a time when information technology helps achieve what matters to people and the state.”

    — Oleh Kononenko managing partner, NOKs fishes

  • “The #ReadCarefully project makes us, as consumers of information, pay attention to details we might not have noticed before. For example, after reading an interview we instinctively judge it: this part is good, that part less so. Usually we judge only the interviewee, but it is the interviewer who “conducts” the interview, and whether the final product is interesting depends on their professionalism. So we turn the reader’s eye from the interviewee to the interviewer. Through the lens of the journalist’s work we can form a fuller picture and a balanced view of any interview.”

    — Maksym Stepanenko co-author of the #ReadCarefully project

  • “Such research is essential and has long been common practice in academic discourse. It is even more relevant for the so-called countries of Europe’s “borderland”, Ukraine among them. These countries are defining their own identity in a globalised, postmodern world. At the same time they stand “on the edge”, where European and Asian value models meet, constantly competing for dominance and combining in various ways. So this kind of research helps us understand where different types of values stand.”

    — Vitalii Kyrychenko deputy development director, NOKs fishes

  • “NOKS FISHES socio-political projects help you not to get lost in today’s media environment and to get an accurate, complete picture of what is happening in the country’s political life. Conscious consumption of information and responsibly forming your own opinion are everyone’s personal tasks, but NOKS FISHES products make it much easier, because objective and comprehensive projects show exactly what deserves attention.”

    — Olesia Chernysh the project’s inspiring leader

  1. Oleh Kononenko
  2. Kateryna Nazar
  3. Kateryna Nazar
  4. Serhii Vedmytskyi

Back to top